万章下 · 第 03 / 09 章 · 孟子 5B.3
《孟子·万章下》5B.3:友其德,不以贵贱长幼相挟
孟子论交友时把年龄、地位、亲属背景都拿掉,只保留“德”这一条,说明真正的朋友关系不是依附结构,而是共同向德看齐。
万章问曰:「敢问友。」孟子曰:「不挟长,不挟贵,不挟兄弟而友。友也者,友其德也,不可以有挟也。孟献子,百乘之家也,有友五人焉:乐正裘、牧仲,其三人则予忘之矣。献子之与此五人者友也,无献子之家者也。此五人者亦有献子之家,则不与之友矣。非惟百乘之家为然也,虽小国之君亦有之。费惠公曰:『吾于子思则师之矣,吾于颜般则友之矣,王顺、长息,则事我者也。』非惟小国之君为然也,虽大国之君亦有之。晋平公之于亥唐也,入云则入,坐云则坐,食云则食。虽疏食菜羹,未尝不饱,盖不敢不饱也。然终于此而已矣,弗与共天位也,弗与治天职也,弗与食天禄也。士之尊贤者也,非王公之尊贤也。舜尚见帝,帝馆甥于贰室,亦飨舜,迭为宾主,是天子而友匹夫也。用下敬上,谓之贵贵;用上敬下,谓之尊贤。贵贵、尊贤,其义一也。」
英文参考译文
Wan Chang asked Mencius, saying, 'I venture to ask the principles of friendship.' Mencius replied, 'Friendship should be maintained without any presumption on the ground of one's superior age, or station, or the circumstances of his relatives. Friendship with a man is friendship with his virtue, and does not admit of assumptions of superiority. There was Meng Xian, chief of a family of a hundred chariots. He had five friends, namely, Yue Zheng Qiu, Mu Zhong, and three others whose names I have forgotten. With those five men Xian maintained a friendship, because they thought nothing about his family. If they had thought about his family, he would not have maintained his friendship with them. Not only has the chief of a family of a hundred chariots acted thus. The same thing was exemplified by the sovereign of a small State. The duke Hui of Bi said, "I treat Zi Si as my Teacher, and Yan Ban as my Friend. As to Wang Shun and Chang Xi, they serve me." Not only has the sovereign of a small State acted thus. The same thing has been exemplified by the sovereign of a large State. There was the duke Ping of Jin with Hai Tang - when Tang told him to come into his house, he came; when he told him to be seated, he sat; when he told him to eat, he ate. There might only be coarse rice and soup of vegetables, but he always ate his fill, not daring to do otherwise. Here, however, he stopped, and went no farther. He did not call him to share any of Heaven's places, or to govern any of Heaven's offices, or to partake of any of Heaven's emoluments. His conduct was but a scholar's honouring virtue and talents, not the honouring them proper to a king or a duke. Shun went up to court and saw the sovereign, who lodged him as his son-in-law in the second palace. The sovereign also enjoyed there Shun's hospitality. Alternately he was host and guest. Here was the sovereign maintaining friendship with a private man. Respect shown by inferiors to superiors is called giving to the noble the observance due to rank. Respect shown by superiors to inferiors is called giving honour to talents and virtue. The rightness in each case is the same.'
重点修订页
人工补强的解释层
核心问题
为什么孟子说交友不能挟长、挟贵、挟兄弟?
直接回答
因为一旦把年龄、权位或门第带进友道,关系就会滑成依附、利用或摆设。只有以德相交,朋友才不是彼此装点,而是彼此校正。
第一性原理
真正能帮助人成长的关系,必须让可敬之处来自德性本身,而不是借外部位置压住对方。
为什么重要
这章适合承接“孟子 交友”“friendship and virtue”“平等关系”这类搜索,也能补强 about 页的人格与学习共同体叙述。
延伸阅读
这章在做什么
这章是《万章下》第 3 / 9 章,最直接的进入线索是“敢问友”。放回全卷,它讨论的是知人、求学与名实之辨,并可与仁政、浩然之气互相印证。
更宽的搜索入口
如果你带着更宽的问题进入这一章,先从正确的 hub 页进入
全卷语境
《万章下》偏重知人、求学与名实是否相副的问题。
引用提示
不要只把它读成社交礼仪。孟子是在重新定义友谊的权力结构:朋友不是彼此攀附,而是彼此向德负责。