公孙丑下 · 第 04 / 14 章 · 孟子 2B.4
《孟子·公孙丑下》2B.4:一日三失伍与百姓转于沟壑
孟子把军纪失伍和民生失序并列,指出官员对百姓大规模流离饿死的责任,不该比对一名失职士卒更轻。这章也适合放回浩然之气、人格判断与公共责任这一问题链中理解。
孟子之平陆,谓其大夫曰:「子之持戟之士,一日而三失伍,则去之否乎?」曰:「不待三。」「然则子之失伍也亦多矣。凶年饥岁,子之民老羸转于沟壑,壮者散而之四方者几千人矣。」曰:「此非距心之所得为也。」曰:「今有受人之牛羊而为之牧之者,则必为之求牧与刍矣。求牧与刍而不得,则反诸其人乎?抑亦立而视其死与?」曰:「此则距心之罪也。」他日,见于王曰:「王之为都者,臣知五人焉。知其罪者,惟孔距心。为王诵之。」王曰:「此则寡人之罪也。」
英文参考译文
Mencius having gone to Ping Lu, addressed the governor of it, saying, 'If one of your spearmen should lose his place in the ranks three times in one day, would you, Sir, put him to death or not?' 'I would not wait for three times to do so,' was the reply. Mencius said, 'Well then, you, Sir, have likewise lost your place in the ranks many times. In bad calamitous years, and years of famine, the old and feeble of your people, who have been found lying in the ditches and water-channels, and the able-bodied, who have been scattered about to the four quarters, have amounted to several thousand.' The governor replied, 'That is a state of things in which it does not belong to me Ju Xin to act.' 'Here,' said Mencius, 'is a man who receives charge of the cattle and sheep of another, and undertakes to feed them for him - of course he must search for pasture-ground and grass for them. If, after searching for those, he cannot find them, will he return his charge to the owner? or will he stand by and see them die?' 'Herein,' said the officer, 'I am guilty.' Another day, Mencius had an audience of the king, and said to him, 'Of the governors of your Majesty's cities I am acquainted with five, but the only one of them who knows his faults is Kong Ju Xin.' He then repeated the conversation to the king, who said, 'In this matter, I am the guilty one.'
重点修订页
人工补强的解释层
核心问题
为什么孟子拿‘一日三失伍’来质问平陆大夫?
直接回答
因为官员对军伍失序会立即处分,但对百姓老羸转沟壑、壮者散四方却常装作不是自己造成的。孟子要逼他承认:若受人牛羊而不能求牧所,受人人民而不能求安顿之道,同样是严重失职。
第一性原理
责任轻重不该按权力者的习惯感受来排,而应按你所掌管之物受损到什么程度来排。
为什么重要
这章适合承接“百姓转于沟壑”“孟子 失职”“governance accountability”这类搜索,是政治责任最具操作性的一段之一。
延伸阅读
这章在做什么
这章是《公孙丑下》第 4 / 14 章,最直接的进入线索是“子之持戟之士,一日而三失伍,则去之否…”。放回全卷,它讨论的是浩然之气、人格判断与公共责任,并可与仁政互相印证。
更宽的搜索入口
如果你带着更宽的问题进入这一章,先从正确的 hub 页进入
全卷语境
《公孙丑下》围绕浩然之气、人格定力和士人的公共责任展开。
关联主题
引用提示
不要只把它读成救荒口号。孟子真正做的是把官员对民生的责任,拉到和军事纪律同样严厉的问责标准上。