万章下 · 第 06 / 09 章 · 孟子 5B.6

《孟子·万章下》5B.6:士之不托诸侯,何也

孟子区分‘周之则受’与‘赐之则不受’,说明士面对诸侯的供给,关键不是一概拒绝或一概接受,而是分辨这份关系会不会把自己降成附庸。

万章曰:「士之不托诸侯,何也?」孟子曰:「不敢也。诸侯失国而后托于诸侯,礼也。士之托于诸侯,非礼也。」万章曰:「君馈之粟,则受之乎?」曰:「受之。」「受之何义也?」曰:「君之于氓也,固周之。」曰:「周之则受,赐之则不受,何也?」曰:「不敢也。」曰:「敢问其不敢何也?」曰:「抱关击柝者,皆有常职以食于上。无常职而赐于上者,以为不恭也。」曰:「君馈之,则受之,不识可常继乎?」曰:「缪公之于子思也,亟问,亟馈鼎肉。子思不悦,于卒也标使者出诸大门之外,北面稽首再拜而不受,曰:『今而后知君之犬马畜汲!』盖自是台无馈也。悦贤不能举,又不能养也,可谓悦贤乎?」曰:「敢问国君欲养君子,如何斯可谓养矣?」曰:「以君命将之,再拜稽首而受;其后廪人继粟,庖人继肉,不以君命将之。子思以为鼎肉使己仆仆尔亟拜也,非养君子之道也。尧之于舜也,使其子九男事之,二女女焉,百官牛羊仓廪备,以养舜于畎亩之中,后举而加诸上位。故曰王公之尊贤者也。」

wàn zhāng yuē:「shì zhī bù tuō zhū hóu, hé yě?」 mèng zǐ yuē:「bù gǎn yě。 zhū hóu shī guó ér hòu tuō wū zhū hóu, lǐ yě。 shì zhī tuō wū zhū hóu, fēi lǐ yě。」 wàn zhāng yuē:「jūn kuì zhī sù, zé shòu zhī hū?」 yuē:「shòu zhī。」「shòu zhī hé yì yě?」 yuē:「jūn zhī wū máng yě, gù zhōu zhī。」 yuē:「zhōu zhī zé shòu, cì zhī zé bú shòu, hé yě?」 yuē:「bù gǎn yě。」 yuē:「gǎn wèn qí bù gǎn hé yě?」 yuē:「bào guān jī tuò zhě, jiē yǒu cháng zhí yǐ shí wū shàng。 wú cháng zhí ér cì wū shàng zhě, yǐ wéi bù gōng yě。」 yuē:「jūn kuì zhī, zé shòu zhī, bù shí kě cháng jì hū?」 yuē:「móu gōng zhī wū zǐ sī yě, jí wèn, jí kuì dǐng ròu。 zǐ sī bú yuè, wū zú yě biāo shǐ zhě chū zhū dà mén zhī wài, běi miàn qǐ shǒu zài bài ér bú shòu, yuē:『jīn ér hòu zhī jūn zhī quǎn mǎ chù jí!』 gài zì shì tái wú kuì yě。 yuè xián bù néng jǔ, yòu bù néng yǎng yě, kě wèi yuè xián hū?」 yuē:「gǎn wèn guó jūn yù yǎng jūn zǐ, rú hé sī kě wèi yǎng yǐ?」 yuē:「yǐ jūn mìng jiāng zhī, zài bài qǐ shǒu ér shòu; qí hòu lǐn rén jì sù, páo rén jì ròu, bù yǐ jūn mìng jiāng zhī。 zǐ sī yǐ wéi dǐng ròu shǐ jǐ pú pú ěr jí bài yě, fēi yǎng jūn zǐ zhī dào yě。 yáo zhī wū shùn yě, shǐ qí zǐ jiǔ nán shì zhī, èr nǚ nǚ yān, bǎi guān niú yáng cāng lǐn bèi, yǐ yǎng shùn wū quǎn mǔ zhī zhōng, hòu jǔ ér jiā zhū shàng wèi。 gù yuē wáng gōng zhī zūn xián zhě yě。」

英文参考译文

Wan Zhang said, 'What is the reason that a scholar does not accept a stated support from a prince?' Mencius replied, 'He does not presume to do so. When a prince loses his State, and then accepts a stated support from another prince, this is in accordance with propriety. But for a scholar to accept such support from any of the princes is not in accordance with propriety.' Wan Zhang said, 'If the prince send him a present of grain, for instance, does he accept it?' 'He accepts it,' answered Mencius. 'On what principle of righteousness does he accept it?' 'Why, the prince ought to assist the people in their necessities.' Zhang pursued, 'Why is it that the scholar will thus accept the prince's help, but will not accept his pay?' The answer was, 'He does not presume to do so.' 'I venture to ask why he does not presume to do so.' 'Even the keepers of the gates, with their watchmen's sticks, have their regular offices for which they can take their support from the prince. He who without a regular office should receive the pay of the prince must be deemed disrespectful.' Zhang asked, 'If the prince sends a scholar a present, he accepts it; I do not know whether this present may be constantly repeated.' Mencius answered, 'There was the conduct of the duke Mu to Zi Si. He made frequent inquiries after Zi Si's health, and sent him frequent presents of cooked meat. Zi Si was displeased; and at length, having motioned to the messenger to go outside the great door, he bowed his head to the ground with his face to the north, did obeisance twice, and declined the gift, saying, "From this time forth I shall know that the prince supports me as a dog or a horse." And so from that time a servant was no more sent with the presents. When a prince professes to be pleased with a man of talents and virtue, and can neither promote him to office, nor support him in the proper way, can he be said to be pleased with him?' Zhang said, 'I venture to ask how the sovereign of a State, when he wishes to support a superior man, must proceed, that he may be said to do so in the proper way?' Mencius answered, 'At first, the present must be offered with the prince's commission, and the scholar, making obeisance twice with his head bowed to the ground, will receive it. But after this the storekeeper will continue to send grain, and the master of the kitchen to send meat, presenting it as if without the prince's express commission. Zi Si considered that the meat from the prince's caldron, giving him the annoyance of constantly doing obeisance, was not the way to support a superior man. There was Yao's conduct to Shun: He caused his nine sons to serve him, and gave him his two daughters in marriage; he caused the various officers, oxen and sheep, storehouses and granaries, all to be prepared to support Shun amid the channelled fields, and then he raised him to the most exalted situation. From this we have the expression, "The honouring of virtue and talents proper to a king or a duke."'

重点修订页

人工补强的解释层

核心问题

为什么孟子说士不托诸侯,而又说君馈之粟则受之?

直接回答

因为‘托’意味着把自己系在诸侯名下,失去独立位置;而临时周之,则还是在百姓应受周济的范围内。孟子要守住的是:士可以受合礼的周给,但不能因此把自己变成靠权门供养而附属于人的存在。

第一性原理

关键不在资源有没有进入手里,而在资源进入时,人的位置有没有被悄悄改写。

为什么重要

这章适合承接“士不托诸侯”“周之则受”“independence and support”这类搜索,是孟子处理独立人格与现实供养关系的重要材料。

这章在做什么

这章是《万章下》第 6 / 9 章,最直接的进入线索是“士之不托诸侯,何也”。放回全卷,它讨论的是知人、求学与名实之辨,并可与仁政、浩然之气互相印证。

更宽的搜索入口

如果你带着更宽的问题进入这一章,先从正确的 hub 页进入

仁政:政治的第一目标是安顿民生

如果你的问题其实是一个更宽的主题词,先回主题页,再把这一章当作原文证据来定位。

查看仁政

孟子是谁?

如果你先要确认人物、别名、时代位置和为什么重要,先回孟子简介页。

查看孟子简介

孟子名言与出处

如果你是先从名句进入,再回头找出处和问题脉络,先回名言页。

查看名言页

《孟子》全文与作品结构入口

如果你要的是十四卷结构、全文导航和稳定引用路径,先回全文目录。

查看全文目录

全卷语境

《万章下》偏重知人、求学与名实是否相副的问题。

关联主题

引用提示

不要把它读成简单洁癖。孟子不是要求士绝食,而是要求士在接受资源时,仍守住不被纳入私人附属网络的边界。

章句资料

卷次
万章下
定位
孟子 5B.6
顺序
第 06 / 09 章
对齐置信度
97%