离娄上 · 第 01 / 28 章 · 孟子 4A.1

《孟子·离娄上》4A.1:徒善不足以为政,徒法不能以自行

孟子既反对只讲善心不落制度,也反对只讲法度不问德性。真正的政治必须把仁心、旧章与执行能力连成一条链。

孟子曰:「离娄之明,公输子之巧,不以规矩,不能成方员。师旷之聪,不以六律,不能正五音。尧舜之道,不以仁政,不能平治天下。今有仁心仁闻而民不被其泽,不可法于后世者,不行先王之道也。故曰:徒善不足以为政,徒法不能以自行。《诗》云:『不愆不忘,率由旧章。』遵先王之法而过者,未之有也。圣人既竭目力焉,继之以规矩准绳,以为方员平直,不可胜用也。既竭耳力焉,继之以六律正五音,不可胜用也。既竭心思焉,继之以不忍人之政而仁覆天下矣。故曰:为髙必因丘陵,为下必因川泽。为政不因先王之道,可谓智乎?是以惟仁者宜在髙位。不仁而在髙位,是播其恶于众也。上无道揆也,下无法守也;朝不信道,工不信度;君子犯义,小人犯刑,国之所存者幸也。故曰:城郭不完,兵甲不多,非国之灾也。田野不辟,货财不聚,非国之害也。上无礼,下无学,贼民兴,丧无日矣。《诗》曰:『天之方蹶,无然泄泄。』泄泄犹沓沓也。事君无义,进退无礼,言则非先王之道者,犹沓沓也。故曰:责难于君谓之恭,陈善闭邪谓之敬,吾君不能谓之贼。」

mèng zǐ yuē:「lí lóu zhī míng, gōng shū zǐ zhī qiǎo, bù yǐ guī jǔ, bù néng chéng fāng yuán。 shī kuàng zhī cōng, bù yǐ liù lǜ, bù néng zhèng wǔ yīn。 yáo shùn zhī dào, bù yǐ rén zhèng, bù néng píng zhì tiān xià。 jīn yǒu rén xīn rén wén ér mín bú bèi qí zé, bù kě fǎ wū hòu shì zhě, bù xíng xiān wáng zhī dào yě。 gù yuē: tú shàn bù zú yǐ wéi zhèng, tú fǎ bù néng yǐ zì xíng。《shī》 yún:『bù qiān bú wàng, lǜ yóu jiù zhāng。』 zūn xiān wáng zhī fǎ ér guò zhě, wèi zhī yǒu yě。 shèng rén jì jié mù lì yān, jì zhī yǐ guī jǔ zhǔn shéng, yǐ wéi fāng yuán píng zhí, bù kě shèng yòng yě。 jì jié ěr lì yān, jì zhī yǐ liù lǜ zhèng wǔ yīn, bù kě shèng yòng yě。 jì jié xīn sī yān, jì zhī yǐ bù rěn rén zhī zhèng ér rén fù tiān xià yǐ。 gù yuē: wéi gāo bì yīn qiū líng, wéi xià bì yīn chuān zé。 wéi zhèng bù yīn xiān wáng zhī dào, kě wèi zhì hū? shì yǐ wéi rén zhě yí zài gāo wèi。 bù rén ér zài gāo wèi, shì bō qí è wū zhòng yě。 shàng wú dào kuí yě, xià wú fǎ shǒu yě; cháo bú xìn dào, gōng bú xìn dù; jūn zǐ fàn yì, xiǎo rén fàn xíng, guó zhī suǒ cún zhě xìng yě。 gù yuē: chéng guō bù wán, bīng jiǎ bù duō, fēi guó zhī zāi yě。 tián yě bú pì, huò cái bú jù, fēi guó zhī hài yě。 shàng wú lǐ, xià wú xué, zéi mín xīng, sāng wú rì yǐ。《shī》 yuē:『tiān zhī fāng juě, wú rán xiè xiè。』 xiè xiè yóu tà tà yě。 shì jūn wú yì, jìn tuì wú lǐ, yán zé fēi xiān wáng zhī dào zhě, yóu tà tà yě。 gù yuē: zé nán wū jūn wèi zhī gōng, chén shàn bì xié wèi zhī jìng, wú jūn bù néng wèi zhī zéi。」

英文参考译文

Mencius said, 'The power of vision of Li Lou, and skill of hand of Gong Shu, without the compass and square, could not form squares and circles. The acute ear of the music-master Kuang, without the pitch-tubes, could not determine correctly the five notes. The principles of Yao and Shun, without a benevolent government, could not secure the tranquil order of the kingdom. There are now princes who have benevolent hearts and a reputation for benevolence, while yet the people do not receive any benefits from them, nor will they leave any example to future ages - all because they do not put into practice the ways of the ancient kings. 'Hence we have the saying: "Virtue alone is not sufficient for the exercise of government; laws alone cannot carry themselves into practice." It is said in the Book of Poetry, "Without transgression, without forgetfulness, Following the ancient statutes." Never has any one fallen into error, who followed the laws of the ancient kings. When the sages had used the vigour of their eyes, they called in to their aid the compass, the square, the level, and the line, to make things square, round, level, and straight: the use of the instruments is inexhaustible. When they had used their power of hearing to the utmost, they called in the pitch-tubes to their aid to determine the five notes - the use of those tubes is inexhaustible. When they had exerted to the utmost the thoughts of their hearts, they called in to their aid a government that could not endure to witness the sufferings of men - and their benevolence overspread the kingdom. 'Hence we have the saying: "To raise a thing high, we must begin from the top of a mound or a hill; to dig to a great depth, we must commence in the low ground of a stream or a marsh." Can he be pronounced wise, who, in the exercise of government, does not proceed according to the ways of the former kings? Therefore only the benevolent ought to be in high stations. When a man destitute of benevolence is in a high station, he thereby disseminates his wickedness among all below him. When the prince has no principles by which he examines his administration, and his ministers have no laws by which they keep themselves in the discharge of their duties, then in the court obedience is not paid to principle, and in the office obedience is not paid to rule. Superiors violate the laws of righteousness, and inferiors violate the penal laws. It is only by a fortunate chance that a State in such a case is preserved. 'Therefore it is said, "It is not the exterior and interior walls being incomplete, and the supply of weapons offensive and defensive not being large, which constitutes the calamity of a kingdom. It is not the cultivable area not being extended, and stores and wealth not being accumulated, which occasions the ruin of a State." When superiors do not observe the rules of propriety, and inferiors do not learn, then seditious people spring up, and that State will perish in no time. It is said in the Book of Poetry, "When such an overthrow of Zhou is being produced by Heaven, Be not ye so much at your ease!" " At your ease;" - that is, dilatory. And so dilatory may those officers be deemed, who serve their prince without righteousness, who take office and retire from it without regard to propriety, and who in their words disown the ways of the ancient kings. Therefore it is said, "To urge one's sovereign to difficult achievements may be called showing respect for him. To set before him what is good and repress his perversities may be called showing reverence for him. He who does not do these things, saying to himself, My sovereign is incompetent to this, may be said to play the thief with him."'

重点修订页

人工补强的解释层

核心问题

为什么孟子说“徒善不足以为政,徒法不能以自行”?

直接回答

因为只有善心而没有制度,人民得不到真实好处;只有法度而没有可承担的人和原则,制度也不会自己运行。政治必须同时解决方向与执行。

第一性原理

秩序不是价值或制度单独一边就能完成的结果,而是价值判断、可传承标准与执行结构共同作用的产物。

为什么重要

这章对现代读者非常有解释力,直接承接“德治与法治”“制度与德性”“Mencius on law and virtue”等搜索意图。

这章在做什么

这章是《离娄上》第 1 / 28 章,最直接的进入线索是“离娄之明,公输子之巧,不以规矩,不能…”。放回全卷,它讨论的是自反、乱世与守道,并可与四端、仁政、浩然之气互相印证。

更宽的搜索入口

如果你带着更宽的问题进入这一章,先从正确的 hub 页进入

四端:仁义礼智的最小可见单位

如果你的问题其实是一个更宽的主题词,先回主题页,再把这一章当作原文证据来定位。

查看四端

孟子是谁?

如果你先要确认人物、别名、时代位置和为什么重要,先回孟子简介页。

查看孟子简介

孟子名言与出处

如果你是先从名句进入,再回头找出处和问题脉络,先回名言页。

查看名言页

《孟子》全文与作品结构入口

如果你要的是十四卷结构、全文导航和稳定引用路径,先回全文目录。

查看全文目录

全卷语境

《离娄上》经常从自反与守道的角度讨论乱世中的行动标准。

关联主题

引用提示

引用时务必保留两半:既不是只讲善心,也不是只讲法条。孟子反对的是任何一边单独自足的幻觉。

章句资料

卷次
离娄上
定位
孟子 4A.1
顺序
第 01 / 28 章
对齐置信度
99%