Li Lou II · Passage 29 / 33 · 孟子 4B.29

Mencius 4B.29: Yu, Ji, and Yan Hui share one Way

Mencius joins Yu and Ji with Yan Hui to show that one Way can require intense public action in one age and quiet steadfastness in another.

禹、稷當平世,三過其門而不入,孔子賢之。顏子當亂世,居於陋巷,一簞食,一瓢飲,人不堪其憂,顏子不改其樂,孔子賢之。孟子曰:「禹、稷、顏回同道。禹思天下有溺者,由己溺之也;稷思天下有饑者,由己饑之也。是以如是其急也。禹、稷、顏子易地則皆然。今有同室之人鬭者,救之,雖被髪纓冠而救之,可也。鄉鄰有鬭者,被髪纓冠而往救之,則惑也,雖閉戶可也。」

yǔ、 jì dāng píng shì, sān guò qí mén ér bú rù, kǒng zǐ xián zhī。 yán zǐ dāng luàn shì, jū wū lòu xiàng, yì dān shí, yì piáo yǐn, rén bù kān qí yōu, yán zǐ bù gǎi qí lè, kǒng zǐ xián zhī。 mèng zǐ yuē:「yǔ、 jì、 yán huí tóng dào。 yǔ sī tiān xià yǒu nì zhě, yóu jǐ nì zhī yě; jì sī tiān xià yǒu jī zhě, yóu jǐ jī zhī yě。 shì yǐ rú shì qí jí yě。 yǔ、 jì、 yán zǐ yì dì zé jiē rán。 jīn yǒu tóng shì zhī rén dòu zhě, jiù zhī, suī bèi fà yīng guān ér jiù zhī, kě yě。 xiāng lín yǒu dòu zhě, bèi fà yīng guān ér wǎng jiù zhī, zé huò yě, suī bì hù kě yě。」

Yu and Ji, in an age when the world was being brought back to order, thrice passed their doors without entering them. Confucius praised them. The disciple Yan, in an age of disorder, dwelt in a mean narrow lane, having his single bamboo-cup of rice, and his single gourd-dish of water; other men could not have endured the distress, but he did not allow his joy to be affected by it. Confucius praised him. Mencius said, 'Yu, Ji, and Yan Hui agreed in the principle of their conduct. Yu thought that if any one in the kingdom were drowned, it was as if he drowned him. Ji thought that if any one in the kingdom suffered hunger, it was as if he famished him. It was on this account that they were so earnest. If Yu and Ji, and Yanzi, had exchanged places, each would have done what the other did. Here now in the same apartment with you are people fighting - you ought to part them. Though you part them with your cap simply tied over your unbound hair, your conduct will be allowable. If the fighting be only in the village or neighbourhood, if you go to put an end to it with your cap tied over your hair unbound, you will be in error. Although you should shut your door in such a case, your conduct would be allowable.'

Priority note

A human-edited reading layer

Central question

Why does Mencius say Yu, Ji, and Yan Hui follow one Way despite such different lives?

Direct answer

Because the Way is not a fixed script of action. Yu and Ji answer famine and drowning in an ordered age; Yan Hui keeps joy and integrity in disorder. Different settings call forth different faithful responses.

First principle

Right action is not one posture detached from circumstance, but a fitting response to the real responsibility present in a given place.

Why it matters

This passage serves searches around Yan Hui, Yu, Ji, one Way, and situational judgment in Mencius.

What this passage is doing

This is passage 29 of 33 in Li Lou II. The cleanest entry point is "Yu, Ji, and Yan Hui agreed in the…". In context, it works as part of Mencius's argument about seeing people clearly, ritual restraint, and governing relationships and can be read alongside Humane government / kingly way.

Broader search routes

If you came here with a wider question, start from the right hub page

Humane government: political order begins with livelihood

If your real query is broader than one citation, start from the theme page and use this passage as proof text.

Open humane government / kingly way

Who is Mencius?

If you first need the person, the aliases, and why he matters, start from the about page.

Open About Mencius

Mencius quotes and sayings

If you arrived through a famous line, start from the quotes hub and then return to the exact passage.

Open Mencius quotes

Mencius full text and works of Mencius

If you need the book structure, the works of Mencius, or where to read the text, start from the full-text hub.

Open the full-text hub

Book context

Li Lou II offers concrete judgments about seeing people, handling relationships, and the discipline of ritual.

Related principles

Citation note

Do not turn it into a license for arbitrary withdrawal or activism. The key line is that if they exchanged places, they would each act accordingly.

Passage profile

Book
Li Lou II
Location
孟子 4B.29
Position
Passage 29 / 33
Alignment confidence
97%